11/11/2024

ChatGPT Vs Google Search

a graphic representing a user searching online

ChatGPT’s search functionality has gone live, and those with Beta accounts or paid subscriptions now have access to it. We firmly believe this new functionality will change the way many, if not all, of us, change our browsing habits, so we wanted to do some analysis into the new functionality provide our feedback and highlights from using it.

Let’s start at the most obvious beginning…

What is ChatGPT Search?

Chat gpt search
According to Open AI, it provides up-to-date information from the internet. Timely responses on current events, sports scores, stocks, etc. You can use it as you would a search engine, and it essentially supplies the most applicable answers.

How is this different from regular ChatGPT?

It’s different for two reasons

  1. The content is more up to date. Where before, you could ask ChatGPT a question or request information, it was limited to the last time the data was crawled (sometimes years old). In this post, we asked who won the World Cup, and it provided the wrong answer. ChatGPT Search’s current functionality is up to the latest training point. However, these training points have not yet been revealed to the public.
  2. And this is the big one–it provides sources and links, enabling verification and further exploration, just like Google (other search engines are available).

We’ve written before how we DON’T use ChatGPT in the deliver of our marketing services. Read that post here. The outdated and incorrect information is one such example. With sources and links for further investigation now in AI Results pages (AIRPs), this can reduce any falsehoods on behalf of the person researching.

So, we’ll try it out. First, we tried a question applicable to one of our clients:

“best gutter cleaners in Melbourne?” It provided a list of 5 businesses, including our client in the first position. Interestingly, it expanded on why each business was selected for the list. Note reviews referenced!

AIRPs of gutter cleaners in melbourne from ChatGPT Search

We wanted to grill ChatGPT a little harder to see what it could do. This time, we have chosen not to fixate on a client, but to search a very competitive keyword from a different angle. And, this time, we’ll compare against the results in Google and see what happens.

We chose: “motorcycle injury lawyer” because it is one of the most expensive keywords you can pay for.

Here are the websites we see in order:

ChatGPT

Arnold Thomas – Google Maps + service page
Henry Carus – Google Maps + homepage
Fittipaldi Injury Lawyers – Google Maps + service page
Kenyon Legal – Google Maps + service page

Google Search

Henry Carus – service page
Millington Legal – service page
Arnold Thomas – service page
Maurice Blackburn – service page
Chat gpt search websites.

It’s interesting to see that they have selected slightly different websites for the top 5. With no information on how their algorithm works, we are commited to analysing and testing to better understand the ChatGPT search algorithm so we can optimise our client’s websites accordingly.

We thought a logical first step would be to compare ChatGPT search results with Microsoft Bing search results. With Microsoft, a significant partner of OpenAI’s, we theorised that their search results would match more closely than Google’s search results. However, they didn’t!

ChatGPT

Arnold Thomas – Google Maps + service page
Henry Carus – Google Maps + homepage
Fittipaldi Injury Lawyers – Google Maps + service page
Kenyon Legal – Google Maps + service page

Google Search

Henry Carus – service page
Millington Legal – service page
Arnold Thomas – service page
Maurice Blackburn – service page

Bing Search

Fittlaw – service page
Arnold Thomas – service page
HCA Lawyers – service page
Millington Legal – service page

The Outcome of Our Use of ChatGPT Search

While other search engine options are throwing anything and everything at you to provide you what they deem the most accurate results, it’s a bit refreshing to have a clean answer.

Using ChatGPT, the AIRPs show a simple, concise list that answers our question. They’ve provided sources and further links if we need them, but it’s stripped down and basic.

Here’s an example of Bing bombarding us with information before showing us the list we wanted (almost below the fold!)

Whether it will remain like that in the future feels unlikely. We’re sure OpenAI will utilise that space for something–say, advertising. But for now, it’s refreshing to spend a bit of time on a search engine (or AI Results Page) that is stripped down and provides the information we’re looking for.

If your business needs guidance on SEO or GEO (AIO – AI Optimisation), we can help.

Get in touch with our digital marketing experts are happy to help. And why not sign up for a complimentary 45-minute strategy session – obligation-free?

Share this:

Facebook
X
LinkedIn

Free 45 Minute Digital Strategy Session

Clients we've worked with

Read more

Related Blog Posts

google ai mode - best gutter cleaners in melbourne

How to Get a Local Business Into Google AI Mode: The PorterVac Case Study

SEO for Occupational Therapists

llms.txt

What is llms.txt?

Get a Free consultation to boost your business

What you'll get

Free 45 Minute Digital Strategy Session

We’ll get in touch with you to arrange a time for your session and gain some initial background on your business needs